Homemade NY ice cream.
Low in pretension & corporate gimmicks but high in quality & rich in love.
NEW LOCATION SPRING 2024
BEACON, NY
Stay in touch on Instagram or Facebook for the latest updates.
Our Story
Five Pennies Creamery is the brainchild of Dan Levine. As a native New Yorker and Brooklynite for over 40 years, Dan set out to create a mom and pop shop that reflected a classic, and sometimes forgotten, New York.
Named after the timeless film, The Five Pennies, which chronicles the life of jazz singer Red Nichols, & tells the story of a man who values love over career ambition-- our ice cream is just that. We're low in pretension & corporate gimmicks, but high in quality & rich in love.
After serving the Rockville Centre community for over a decade, Five Pennies Creamery closed its doors in December 2022 with the message:
“Serving this community has been one of my proudest accomplishments and highlights of my life. I’ve seen generations of kids and families grow; I have grown with them. … Thank you for helping shape the community around the shop and supporting us for so many years. I’m humbled by your collective kindness, honored to serve so many, and proud of any joy Five Pennies may have brought to your life.”
Five Pennies Creamery will be reopening in the Hudson Valley in Spring 2024.
"With just five pennies, if they're these FIVE pennies, you'll be a millionaire"
FLAVORS
These are just some of the 130 flavors we sell!
Flavors available will change daily, please understand not all flavors below will be available.
You may call ahead to inquire about a specific flavor.
Vanilla
chocolate
strawberry
cookies & Cream
Mint chip
Butter Pecan
Rum Raisin
Coffee Chip
Banana PUdding
Toasted Coconut
Vanilla Chip
Cookie Dough
Pralines & Cream
Sundae Best
Smurfs
Cotton Candy
Cake Batter
Birthday Cake
Pistachio
Cinnamon Bun
Salted Caramel
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Boston Cream Pie
Strawberry Oreo
Black RasPberry Chip
Mounds
Lemon Ginger Snap
Black cherry
Creamy Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter Oreo
S'mores
Chocolata
'O'Mazing Oreo
Snickers
Creamsicle
Kit Kat
Mississippi Mud
French Pastry Cheesecake
Curious George
Peaches & Cream
Maple Chip
Apple Pie
Tiramisu
Pumpkin Pecan Swirl
Peppermint Patty
Gingerbread Man
Strawberry Lemonade Ice
Bing Cherry Ice
Lemon Ice
Mango Ice